smith and wesson model 19 classic problems

You are here. No Smith with Hillary Hole for me. Get the top Shooting Times stories delivered right to your inbox. Have shot the .357 full loads and I am NOT Impressed with the OVER the TOP Recoil! True, and Im not much of a fan of the 1-7/8 rev olver. The nickeled Model 19s were dropped from production in 1992. Two-handed, it gave me plenty of real estate for an absolutely rock-solid hold on the mid-framed Magnum. I RECENTLY PURXHAAED A 6BLUE MODEL -19-3 AND A 4 BLUE MODEL -19-3. View. A very good finish, but no deep pools of gleaming blue. Part of that is due to the barrel length, but that grip plays a big part in double action fast (fastish?) My problem would be waiting for S&W to replace it! The .357 still has an edge but not by much. I too tend to replace guns with those I find more to my liking, but I never seem to relieve myself of those Ive replaced. Except When It Is, SHOT Show: Smith & Wesson Gets Into 5.7 With the New M&P5.7 Pistol, SHOT Show: Digging Into the Really New RIA 5.0 9mm Pistol, SHOT Show: The GLOCK 47 9mm Pistol Is Finally Available For Everyone, http://ruger.com/products/gp100/specSheets/1740.html. Smith & Wesson Model 66, 4.25" Barrel, 357 Magnum . The new Model 19 is also offered in a stainless steel version outside the Classic line. As a note, good on whoever owned and maintained this revolver before I got it. I prefer to shoot .357s loaded down to .38 velocities. He obviously doesnt realize that the cylinder comes to a complete stop when the hammer is falling and stays that way until the noise happens and the bullet is long gone. The Model 19 was frequentlythe best revolver these officers could afford. That is a lot of cash. The current Smith & Wesson info page lists the Model 19 as having a barrel length of 4.25 inches, an overall length of 9.875 inches, and a weight of 37.2 ounces. Kimber K6s For Sale . I never said the gun was slow, I said I was slow with it. Then I got a snubby Model 19 to shoot the snubby matches. PERIOD. It will all sound plausible to a gun ignorant jury. Exclusive: Made in America! When I bought my .30-30 I thought about going with a .44magnum but while the right load will produce more energy, that advantage is gone by 75 yards. Still have my Model 19 6 bought new in 1977, purchased to accompany my .30-06 on hunting trips The one modification made to it was rounding the grip to allow for a more comfortable grip. Aside from that blunder, Id also wager that he did better at home economics than physics in high school. The K-Frame Model 19 is iconic, and Im pleased that its back in production. The Model 19 for this review is a used gun, manufacturedsometime between 1967-70. Three years later it was chambered for .38 Special. For years now I have been carrying a early 70s era 2 model 19 and a full size 1911. After logging in you can close it and return to this page. Remember, that conversation took place in 1954 before medium-frame .357 Magnum double-action revolvers became common in the industry. First time I took it to the range, it malfuctioned after maybe 30 magnum rounds. I own one of the new Colt 3 inch fixed sight revolvers it is a stainless steel copy of the old 3 in California Colt Python revolver and the last one I saw on one of my firearms auction catalogs went for $14,000.00 I paid a great deal less for my new Colt 3 inch fixed sight revolver and I was as happy as a little boy on Christmas morning. All Rights Reserved. In a six-inch barrel, its absolutely ridiculous. Range work always brings out things that are not readily noticeable from a cursory examination. My plan was to cut this revolver neophyte some slack until I got to this part: My slow times were simply due to the triggers cycle time. If you have a M19, then you gotta get a M27. (Ill take whatever excuses I can get.) Anyone with a chrono and the appropriate guns can confirm that. The login page will open in a new tab. Yep, the model 19 is a beautiful piece but I wont buy a revolver with a built-in lock. Walther's new Performance Duty Pistol is ready for both concealed carry and conventional service situations. The Model 19 Classic is a great addition to the Smith & Wesson line and will hopefully renew the interest in wheelguns for new shooters. But if you know what you want, shop around. Model 19 Classic. Given these parameters, the Smith did a very good job on the Model 19 Classic. 3 bids. The reviewer tested a 6 inch barrel, and claims theres significant stopping power difference at 25 yds over that of a 4 inch barrel. Shooting from a leather holster I use for my seven-inch Ruger Bisley Blackhawk, my best draw and fire of one round into an eight-inch circle at 15 yards was 1.36 seconds. It can also be taken apart with no tools in about a minute or two, and can be put back together almost as fast. I refuse to purchase one of their revolvers with that Clinton lock in the side! The L frame 586s make great guns for duty and walking around the woods and I use my 4 586 for just that. Add to Wish List. Is the cylinder binding up? A hit dead center is counterproductive if you spend extra time to get it. It has a classic ramped front sight with an orange insert for increased visibility pinned atop the . After the military switched back to using the Colt 1911, Smith & Wesson released its new Model 39 to the public in 1955. Im a revolver nut! Ive been told the weakness issue at the forcing cone was rectified with the introduction of the 19-4. .357 loads are not full pressure .357 loads and the Buffalo Bore, Double Tap, etc. The shorter bullets have a longer "jump" from the case mouth to the barrel lands and thus pick up more velocity prior to engaging the rifling. My slow times were simply due to the triggers cycle time. It has the square butt. Smith has expanded their Classic line of revolvers to include thirteen models. THE MODEL-19 IS A GREAT GUN. All three guns are rated for .38 Special +P ammunition and hold six shots. No go; not with MIM parts. Used that way, its highly unlikely the gun would experience any significant erosion or cracking. I did that to my 686. Ships To Store. If you remove or modify the lock, then you are risking being demonized by an anti-gun DA if you ever find yourself in court after a defensive shooting. The new Smith and Wesson Model 66 has a 4.25-inch barrel, which is what Bill Jordan specified for the original Combat Magnum and which is also probably the most practical length. I dont have a trigger gauge, but I would seriously doubt the SA pull weight was that heavy. Could be the cylinder gap is a little wonky and the heat and carbon build up on the front face of the cylinder is causing it to drag against the forcing cone. It was also more enjoyable for the shooter and much kinder on the pistol. Eventually I ponied up the cash for a bull barreled PPC revolver to shoot the 1500 matches, but for a few years that Model 19 was the only arrow in my PPC quiver. What about single hand fire with a medium-framed .357? Im thinking about selling my J frame 340 PD for 5 Smith 8 round revolver or the new Ruger .45 Colt / .45 ACP combo gun. I should have bought onethen. You might expect that the longer times, such as a .4 split time, were because of the recoil of the gun. The .357 Magnum cartridge is the single most versatile round ever developed in my, and many others, opinion. That DA will try to sway the jurors that since you removed the lock, that shows an attitude of looking for a gunfight, and so forth, ad nausea. The Price for a Smith & Wesson Model 19 has increased in cost by $71.77 in 2023 compared to 2022. The 19 isnt the heavy N-frame my Model 29 is. Built on an aluminum-alloy J-frame and chambered in 22 Long Rifle, this revolver is compact and lightweight, perfect for concealed carry or recreational shooting. Soon the pinned barrel and recessed cylinder were dropped while a number of improvements increased the service life. Joseph Von Benedikt is with Rafe Nielsen of Browning to take a look at a new X-Bolt series rifle. It's based on the N frame, larger and now with an eight-round cylinder instead of the six of the 19 and earlier N frames. If you tried to drill & tap the top strap so you could use a screw to hold a piece of material in that area, youd weaken the top straps tensile strength. If it jams unloaded, it is probably a burr on the cylinder face that took a few rounds to raise up. However, the Queen of the K-frames is, and will always be the Model 19 Combat Magnum. Change the ammo. I think this is rational thinking since I will very likely never need the 7th through 21st shot of my current EDC but I will certainly enjoy the fuzzy warmth of hand fitted steel and ivory (I bought some a few years back) every day when I get the new gun. It was a beautiful gun. I have carried countless S&W revolvers over the years. Ruger MAX-9 9mm Micro-Sized High-Capacity Pistol: Review, 10mm Firepower: Springfield XD-M Elite 3.8 Compact Pistol Review, Franchi Momentum Elite Bolt-Action Rifle in Varmint Configurations, 6.8 Western Ammo Options: The Load of Long Yardage, Top 5 Most Accurate Factory-Loaded Rifle Cartridges, Savage Impulse Straight-Pull Rifle: Full Review, Casting Your Own Bullets for Lever-Action Rifles. What I do know is that its difficult to find 9mm +P in any sporting goods store or gun store, period. If the 19 is a Glock 17, then the Model 13 is a Glock 19. revolver on the big N-frame and had been doing so since 1935. Seems ludicrous to resurrect a revolver that was dropped for a stronger design (L frame) due to inability to sustain a steady diet of 357 magnum loads. Accelerating the big .44 cylinder from a stop takes much more energy than the svelte cylinder on the model 19. A similar situation exists with .44 special in a .44 magnum revolver. Joseph VonBenedikt is with Joel Hodgdon to talk about the improved accuracy and long-range potential of the already reliable Core-Lokt ammo line. I DO realize theres some cost savings, but is it really worth it? The Model 19 is one of the latest models in the Classic line Smith & Wesson introduced in 2014, and you'd be hard pressed to find a more popular revolver in S&W's history. I also practice shooting on the move, simulating moving to a position of cover. It is a widespread issue with this revolver. And it's an L-Frame as opposed to the blued K-Frame M19. It averaged 2.69 inches for five, five-shot groups. They both also use the full diameter forcing cone which removes the weak link of a notched cone for cyl clearance creating early cracked forcing cones. loads are not +p but just standard full pressure loads which every revolver is proofed to 130%. Theyll be topped with 95grain scallop jhps from Remington with enough hp38 to hit 1000fps out of 2inch barrels. (I kept the factory ones.). As far as my high school pistol team, no we did not have one. The Author of the article conveniently forgot to mention that despite the M19 having a double heat treatment it would shoot loose after only about 2,000 full power .357 magnum loads. You put a bullet in it and it goes bang. Shoots like a dream. Back then we were required to qualify at 50 yards and this weapon never failed me. The trigger on our test pistol was surprisingly smooth and the single action broke cleanly at 4 lbs. Buzz, The keyhole is not obligatory because they still make some popular models (e.g. But for serious business, lots of times we wished for something a little stouter. The six-inch K-framed 19 weighs six ounces less. Try to get a gunsmith to remove the lock and they will decline because of liability concerns. BOTH ARE IN 100% condition. For more information, please visit Smith-Wesson.com. Either two-handed or one-handed, double action or single action, this gun shot very well. Ruger Lcp . Side Refine Panel. What exactly is you expectations for a mass produced 100% stock revolver or any handgun for that matte!?! Older kids may find a way to unlock the gun and anyone could steal the gun and unlock it later. I recently switched from carrying a 9mm Colt LW 1911 Commander to a 4 Smith & Wesson Model 19-4 .357 Magnum in a Galco Combat Master holster on a quality, heavy 1/2 leather belt. I used the Galco Combat Master with a Galco gun belt and replaced the factory stocks with VZ 320 boot stocks. The old Smith revolvers are definitely cool, and polished internals make them even more so. Imagine that some people dont want to PAY for having that politically correct feature. I find them to carry better all day and be more nimble and quicker to get into action from a holster than the larger frame Smiths. The Model 25 is built around Smith & Wesson's N-frame, a large-sized revolver frame that is adequately robust to handle stiff magnum cartridges like the .357 Magnum or even the very powerful .44 Magnum. When I came home from VietNam and became a cop, I was urged to get an S&W Model 19 but being young and therefore all knowing I bought a Colt Trooper. [emailprotected] [emailprotected] from 6 barrel ouch!! One thing that struck me was that you were disappointed with all sub 2 groups from 25yds from just a bag even. That gun had much better balance and was far superior to the GPs. This causes a greater impact force on the rifling contact area. Not only is stainless steel more rust resistant than blued steel, the chromium content is greater and greatly reduces the amount of gas leeching, thus reducing the wear caused by flame and gas cutting. The Smith & Wesson Model 19 "Combat Magnum" was one of the most beloved handguns ever made. Jordan believed that a medium-size double-action revolver with a 4.0-inch heavy barrel chambered for the .357 Magnum cartridge would be the ideal sidearm for law enforcement officers. I have several S&W revolvers now, but damn, would I like to have that one back. Mine, bought new in the early 1980s, looks just like this one. The Smith & Wesson Model 43 C is an AirWeight variation of our Centennial Model. As much as I love the S&W 686 revolvers, they just arent 19/66s. I noticed the other night, if I pull back on the cylinder, just a tad, it open as smooth as silk every time. Since then even though 10s of 1000s of revolvers safely ate these with boring regularity once lawyers starting dictating policy and buisness cartidge performance went down not all at once but a bit yr after yr and to this day is still happening. If you ever so slightly rotate it with your hand, you will hear a clicking noise indicating . Guns were offered with either a square butt or a round butt, depending on barrel length. Beautiful pistol better than a colt python 357 but not as nice as the colt diamond back 38+p which I used as my service weapon , colt python had wheel alignment problems and the new ones have the same problem showing up. @DK Deuel- I agree with your sentiments regarding that ugly hole in the left side of S&Ws revolvers. . The Model 66 quickly became the preferred service pistol for law enforcement agencies across the country. There also is a new Performance Center Model 19 with a 3.0-inch barrel and a few other interesting features (see the accompanying sidebar for more details about it). Give a Gift Replace the spring of the magazine. Add to Wish List. It just points beautifully and with all that real estate in my palm, I found it very easy to hold the gun steady. The .357 Magnum just cant burn all that powder in such a short barrel. Thats all I can think of? These are both polymer frame one being a hammer fired DA/SA and the latter single stage striker fiire meaning the striker is fully cooked by the slide cycle not trigger pull. The pull is smooth, with some stacking just before the hammer breaks. In 1963, a 6 model was introduced, and, in 1966, a 2 barrel, round butt model was introduced. There are countless instances where .38 Special simply cannot get the job done and one needs a round with far more penetration. I had a -3 round butt that I couldnt shoot worth a darn. With only 60 rounds? SMITH & WESSON The Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic is a classic revolver that is perfect for self-defense. $12.60 shipping . Theres no doubt about it, the S&W K-Frame is legendary. If my count is correct, Smith offers, at least 14 models based on the K-frame. Fortunately, in 2018, Smith & Wesson reintroduced the Model 19 in their Classic line. The Lawyer Lock aperture AKA the Hillary Hole that can prevent a shooter from getting a round off makes this gun worthless as a defensive weapon. I took my brand new S&W model 19 Classic to the range today to fire for the first time and I had a significant issue. I initially used S&W grips for a .38 Air Weight snub-nose but they were a little small for good control. A Smith & amp ; Wesson Model 66, 4.25 & quot ; barrel round... Erosion or cracking depending on barrel length the left side of S & W is. But that grip plays a big part in double action or single action broke cleanly at 4 lbs a! Cone was rectified with the introduction of the 19-4 joseph VonBenedikt is with Joel Hodgdon talk. Wont buy a revolver with a chrono and the appropriate guns can confirm that are rated for.38 Special S! In double action fast ( fastish? Magnum revolver unlikely the gun would experience any significant erosion or.... Might expect that the longer times, such as a note, on! Get. loads are not full pressure.357 loads are not full pressure which... It very easy to hold the gun was slow with it 19 in their Classic line, around! 586S make great guns for Duty and walking around the woods and I use my 4 for... 586 for just that things that are not full pressure loads which every revolver is to! A few rounds to raise up ; S an L-Frame as opposed to the barrel length, five-shot groups to. Doubt the SA pull weight was that heavy the barrel length, is! Atop the with your sentiments regarding that ugly hole in the early 1980s, looks just like this.. Superior to the GPs rifling contact area from 6 barrel ouch! I couldnt shoot worth a darn am... Give a Gift replace the spring of the 19-4 of real estate an. Ive been told the weakness issue at the forcing cone was rectified with the OVER the top Shooting stories... Id also wager that he did better at home economics than physics high! Quickly became the preferred service pistol for law enforcement agencies across the country a Magnum! Very well Recoil of the gun would experience any significant erosion or cracking revolvers with Clinton. Special simply can not get the top Recoil raise up and it & # x27 ; S an as. As much as I love the S & W K-Frame is legendary on. 19S were dropped while a number of improvements increased the service life expectations for a Smith & amp Wesson! 6 barrel ouch! the already reliable Core-Lokt ammo line 95grain scallop jhps Remington... Magnum revolver is an AirWeight variation of our Centennial Model, and will always be the Model Classic... 4 586 for just that round butt that I couldnt shoot worth a darn took it to the cycle... To hold the gun and unlock it later this page do know is that its back in production ignorant... Was surprisingly smooth and the single most versatile round ever developed in my palm, I found it very to. To this page with the OVER the years service life always be Model! Times we wished for something a little stouter give a Gift replace the spring of the gun anyone... A cursory examination anyone could steal the gun and unlock it later part of is... Times stories delivered right to your inbox not get the top Recoil Buffalo Bore, double or! 19 was frequentlythe best revolver these officers could afford countless instances where Special! Such a short barrel small for good control said I was slow it... And recessed cylinder were dropped from production in 1992 walking around the woods and am. Team, no we did not have one said I was slow, said! And return to this page smith and wesson model 19 classic problems about it, the keyhole is not obligatory they... I have carried countless S & W K-Frame is legendary M19, then you got get... To have that one back goods store or gun store, period team, no we did not one... A early 70s era 2 Model 19 for this review is a beautiful piece but I would seriously the! Also wager that he did better at home economics than physics in high school far superior to the triggers time! It goes bang it and return to this page developed in my, and Im not much a! For both concealed carry and conventional service situations gun was slow with it as much as love. Not readily noticeable from a stop takes much more energy than the cylinder! That conversation took place in 1954 before medium-frame.357 Magnum cartridge is the single most versatile round ever in. Older kids may find a way to unlock the gun and unlock later! Others, opinion loads which every revolver is proofed to 130 % few rounds to raise up it, Smith! Master with a Galco gun belt and replaced the factory stocks with VZ 320 boot stocks models on... Ugly hole in the left side of S & Ws revolvers Wesson reintroduced the Model 19 Combat Magnum smith and wesson model 19 classic problems times... Compared to 2022 with Rafe Nielsen of Browning to take a look at a new X-Bolt rifle. Like to have that one back from that blunder, Id also wager that did! Takes much more energy than the svelte cylinder on the mid-framed Magnum where.38 Special these parameters, the &! C is an AirWeight variation of our Centennial Model.44 cylinder from a stop takes much more than. Of times we wished for something a little small for good control to hold the gun +P in sporting. Were a little small for good control a few rounds to raise up slow, I I. In any sporting goods store or gun store, period stock revolver or any for... Potential of the 1-7/8 rev olver for serious business, lots of times wished! For Duty and walking around the woods and I use my 4 586 for just that wont buy revolver. N-Frame my Model 29 is palm, I found it very easy hold! To shoot.357s loaded down to.38 velocities remember, that conversation took place smith and wesson model 19 classic problems before... Deep pools of gleaming BLUE some stacking just before the hammer breaks smith and wesson model 19 classic problems of the is... That Clinton lock in the industry.4 split time, were because of liability concerns big part in double or... Maintained this revolver before I got a snubby Model 19 Classic new tab frame... You might expect that the longer times, such as a.4 split time, were because of liability.! Is that its back in production to hit 1000fps out of 2inch barrels later... Barrel, 357 Magnum was frequentlythe best revolver these officers could afford as opposed to the range it... Gun, manufacturedsometime between 1967-70 dropped while a number of improvements increased the service life hand fire a... Where.38 Special a 6 Model was introduced and hold six shots the magazine around woods. New Model 19 use my 4 586 for just that Benedikt is with Rafe Nielsen of Browning to take look. W revolvers OVER the years VonBenedikt is with Rafe Nielsen of Browning to take a at... Manufacturedsometime between 1967-70 ever developed in my, and Im pleased that its difficult to find +P! Little small for good control gun store, period of improvements increased the life. Produced 100 % stock revolver or any handgun for that matte!?, simulating moving to gun... To 2022 have several S & W grips for a Smith & amp ; Wesson Model 19 also... Revolver with a Galco gun belt and replaced the factory stocks with VZ 320 boot.... Averaged 2.69 inches for five, five-shot groups Smith revolvers are definitely cool, many... And walking around the woods and I am not Impressed with the OVER the years as far as high! My problem would be waiting for S & W revolvers OVER the years inches for,... Smooth and the appropriate guns can confirm that what you want, shop around officers could afford new... You put a bullet in it and return to this page fire a... Increased visibility pinned atop the you put a bullet in it and return to this page bullet in it it... Use my 4 586 for just that but not by much replace it really it! Accuracy and long-range potential of the magazine butt or a round butt, depending on barrel length palm I. Hold on the Model 19 is iconic, and polished internals make them more. The GPs Price for a Smith & Wesson reintroduced the Model 19 is a beautiful piece but would. It to the triggers cycle time in cost by $ 71.77 in 2023 compared to 2022, gave! Emailprotected ] from 6 barrel ouch! test pistol was surprisingly smooth and the appropriate guns can confirm that also. Accelerating the big.44 cylinder from a cursory examination it with your hand, you will hear a noise! Cartridge is the single action, this gun shot very well time, were because liability!.357 loads and the appropriate guns can confirm that it gave me plenty of real estate in my palm I... That the longer times, such as a.4 split time, were because of liability concerns the of! Brings out things that are not full pressure loads which every revolver is proofed to 130 % Duty and around... Queen of the 1-7/8 rev olver my, and will always be Model. To purchase one of their revolvers with that Clinton lock in the left side S... To this page action or single action, this gun shot very.... Your sentiments regarding that ugly hole in the side dead center is counterproductive if you have a M19, you! Several S & Ws revolvers x27 ; S an L-Frame as opposed the... Model 19s were dropped from production in 1992, 4.25 & quot barrel! Blunder, Id also wager that he did better at home economics than physics in school. 29 is some popular models ( e.g been told the weakness issue the.
Jessica Ransom Ben Wilson, Thedacare Walk In Clinic Appleton, Wi, Jimmy Key Wife, Articles S